What a Production!

Discovery issues in litigation

Just about every litigation matter has a certain amount of discovery that needs to be done. Discovery is a term used to describe the gathering and reviewing of documents, pictures, recordings, and any other item that might be relevant to a case. Attorneys for each party typically send a request for the other party to produce a long list of items as part of their representation in the beginning of a case. Sometimes parties are asked to bring the items with them to court or to a deposition where discovery will also include their answering questions of the opposing attorney. Sometimes the information is simply sent from one attorney to the other. The amount of discovery depends on the particular facts of the case and the type of case.

In matrimonial law, everything that ever happened during the entire marriage is relevant. Naturally, attorneys and their clients need to decide what is most important. Cost is an important factor for many clients. It takes time to review and analyze information. Some wonder whether it even has to be done. At the very least, it is important and necessary for the attorney to review some basic financial information. If a client is well informed of the family finances, does not suspect the other party of any “funny business,” and my initial check and balance does not produce any red flags, then we can discuss limiting the discovery to that point. If any of those conditions does not exist, then prudence dictates more substantial discovery and the cost is justified.  Discovery beyond financial concerns will often be necessary when there are disputes over custody or regarding fault in the marital breakdown.

Attorneys, with their client’s help, will discuss the issues thoroughly and identify what information may be necessary to help prove or disprove a claim. In the end, the attorney uses the discovery to evaluate the strength of the case, make recommendations for settlement and prepare for trial. Discovery is very important for a successful resolution of a case.

Need to discuss your case?  Get a free phone consultation from Bellenot & Bouford.

Why Do Judges Do That?

Connecticut Law Firm

THE RISKS OF TRIAL

As a trial attorney, I am always assessing the risks of trial – or other hearing before a judge. My assessment is fluid, frequently changing based on party conduct, evidence reviewed, strength and weaknesses of my available positions, and the governing law and how judges interpret the law. Let’s focus on the last factor, interpretation of the law.

There are many steps that must be taken before an idea becomes a law. Once the final language is approved by the legislature, it becomes binding on the applicable public. How the language is actually interpreted is up to the judicial branch. The opinion of the judges on the particular law is conveyed via the decisions that are rendered following a hearing. Here is the not-so-obvious truth: judges often differ in their opinions, making predicting the outcome of a legal dispute a bit difficult. Add to this the differing fact patters of every case and the risk of not predicting correctly is compounded.

People going through litigation are necessarily biased and often think that there is only one possible outcome to a trial; a decision in their favor. They expect “justice” to be done. A difficult part of my job is to get clients to understand and acknowledge that laws and how they are applied can be interpreted differently and thus there is an element of risk in taking a dispute to trial. Sometimes judges think differently. Sometimes judges just get it wrong. Even members of the same Appellate and Supreme Court often differ – and even argue – about a decision after hearing the same attorneys present the same case (!)

I share my risk assessment with my clients and it is up to them to decide how to proceed. Usually, if there is a reasonable settlement option, my recommendation is to take it. I am not afraid of trial and actually enjoy the process from a professional standpoint. I do, however, recognize that beyond the risks, there is a significant financial and emotional component to going through a trial.